I’m in mourning. Today I had to throw out an entire package of cheese – unopened. That is dreadfully wrong, it should never happen.
I love the Extra Sharp New York Cheddar by Applegate Farms. It’s one of my most favorite cheeses ever. It’s sliced so it’s easy to use to make a grilled cheese sandwich. It’s easy to break into pieces and eat with crackers. For that matter, it’s easy to break it into pieces and eat all by itself while sipping a glass of wine. It’s white – no food coloring to make it look yellow. It’s on the creamier side for texture (I’m sure they make it that way on purpose to be able to slice it) but it has that lovely extra sharp bite to it. Delightful. It’s also on the expensive side – there are only about 8 slices in a package.
I buy it from Whole Foods which seems to be the only store where I regularly shop to carry it (well I did find it in one other store, but that’s about 10 miles in the opposite direction of anyplace else I go). WF doesn’t always have it. So after several weeks of no cheese to be found, leaving the store every week with that desolate feeling of having only mediocre cheese to eat… I was delighted to find it back in stock last Sunday when I did my weekly shopping. I bought 2 packages. I would have bought more if I could find a way to keep it fresh without having to freeze it. As it stands, even 5 days was a little too much this time.
Naturally I opened one package immediately and proceeded to polish it off this week. It was lovely. Today I went to open the second package… Somehow from the time I picked it up in the store and got it into my refrigerator, the seal had broken on the packaging, it was no longer airtight. I looked at all the lovely cheese… all the lovely blue/green colored cheese. Yes, it had mold all over it. There was air and condensation in the package. My heart sank.
I wanted to cry. All my lovely cheese – all the wrong color. For about 20 seconds I considered the possibility of salvaging some of it, but decided the probable intestinal complications were not worth the effort. I put it into the freezer (where all the “old” food goes before being taken out in the trash at the end of the week) .
*sigh* I guess I have to wait until Sunday and hope for the best. I will be carefully checking any other packages I find. I can’t deal with the trauma of having to get rid of any more of my favorite cheese. We shall hope for the best.

Nibbles at the Table